An Ethiopian Airlines cargo flight bound from Ethiopia to Israel took off, only to circle around the airport and ultimately return to its origin. The reason? There was an Indonesian pilot onboard, so he had to be removed, and then the flight could continue.
Israel enforces new citizenship rules for airline crews
We recently saw a flydubai Boeing 737 pilot attempt to kill the captain on his flight, so that he could gain control of the aircraft, and crash it into Tel Aviv’s Ben Gurion Airport (TLV). Fortunately he was stopped thanks to the heroic captain and passengers, as this was so close to being a tragedy of unimaginable scale.
In light of that attempted terror attack, Israel has started formally restricting the nationalities of the pilots and flight attendants working flights to Israel. Long story short, crew members can not have citizenship in countries that don’t have diplomatic relations with Israel. Even dual citizenship is a disqualifier.
In theory there were previously some restrictions intended to be in place in these situations, but they weren’t consistently enforced. That brings us to this situation, where there absolutely was enforcement.
On Monday, October 12, 2026, an Ethiopian Airlines cargo Boeing 737 was supposed to operate from Addis Ababa’s Bole International Airport (ADD) to Tel Aviv. The plane took off at 1:40AM, with flight number ET3414. However, it didn’t make it very far.
The plane flew north toward Israel for around 30 minutes, before turning around, and then circling near Addis Ababa, reportedly to dump fuel. This was because there was an Indonesian pilot onboard, and anyone with Indonesian citizenship isn’t allowed to operate a flight to Israel.
The plane ended up landing back in Addis Ababa at 3:22AM local time, 1hr42min after it initially departed.
There was then a crew change, and at 5:41AM the plane once again took off to Tel Aviv, where it landed at 9:15AM, after a flight time of 3hr34min.
How was this crewing mistake made in the first place?
Obviously airlines have had to make quite some updates to their crew scheduling for Israel flights in recent times, given the new restrictions on pilots and flight attendants. In particular, even people with dual citizenship are being banned from flying to the country, so that’s leading to a logistical headache for airlines. For that matter, it relies on crews also being honest about their citizenship, since it can be easy enough to hide dual citizenship.
However, it shouldn’t be that hard to follow the rules. According to reports, Ethiopian Airlines only sent the crew manifest for this flight after the plane took off from Ethiopia. Then when the mistake was caught (almost immediately), the plane was forced to return to its origin.
So it sounds like Ethiopian Airlines should’ve caught the mistake before the flight even departed. For that matter, it’s puzzling how the plane was even allowed to depart without that list being submitted. I get that there’s a difference between departure clearance and landing clearance, but still…
Bottom line
An Ethiopian Airlines cargo jet flying from Addis Ababa to Tel Aviv had to turn around shortly after takeoff, after it was discovered that one of the pilots onboard was Indonesian. Israel has started banning crew members who hold citizenship with countries they don’t have diplomatic relations with, which is fair enough, in light of the shocking events.
In this case, the airline didn’t send the crew manifest until after takeoff, and then that ended poorly for the carrier. I’m sure airlines will soon get used to this strict system.
What do you make of this Ethiopian Airlines “flight to nowhere?”
Imagine the outcry if Israeli crew were similarly banned from flying to the same countries whose crew they're banning...
That should not have been an issue from the get go. Indonesian passports have enormous stamp in it stating: " Not valid for travel to Israel". That's due to Indonesia being a world's largest Muslim country and not having a diplomatic relationship with Israel. They also do not admit holders of Israeli passports. Simple reciprocity here. I'm pretty sure bounced pilot new it well. Even though he may have been admitted into Israel under good...
That should not have been an issue from the get go. Indonesian passports have enormous stamp in it stating: " Not valid for travel to Israel". That's due to Indonesia being a world's largest Muslim country and not having a diplomatic relationship with Israel. They also do not admit holders of Israeli passports. Simple reciprocity here. I'm pretty sure bounced pilot new it well. Even though he may have been admitted into Israel under good will principal, he would have terrible consequences from his home government, up and including death penalty.
Oh the wonders of propaganda.
And the fool spreading it.
It's because Indonesia does not recognize Israel. Unlike Taiwan, who doesn't have nukes or gold to bully their way into international recognition.
However, citizens of either state can obtain a visa to enter the other.
No Indonesian who have visited Israel has been know to be executed due to the visit.
And there is no such entry into Israel or any other state under "good will principal" (sic)
Seems to assign fault to the airline. What about the pilot? Should people be allowed to fly airplanes when they don't even know their citizenship requires that they avoid certain routes? Yet he said nothing.
People should not be allowed to fly any planes ever again.
Problem is we have too many dinosaurs that don't go extinct.
"NAZA"
You Reap what you sow! you cannot continue to Invade,Pillage,Steal Lands,Homes,commit Genocide and not have any consequences? A few Israeli Leaders have made a Target on All Israelis Backs, this will take years & years to go away. Hollywood better start churning out propaganda movies by the Hundreds again. Don't believe this, Look up "NAZA".
It's not immediately clear to me how any flight could operate with crew ineligible to enter the destination country. Is the assumption that they'd only do quick turns and never have to enter the country?
To my knowledge the pilot was eligible to enter the country, but was not eligible to work flights to/from the country
When I read 'pilot "breaches" rules,' I was bracing for a horrifying cockpit intrusion story, not a paperwork mistake! Technically a regulatory breach, sure, but "noncompliance" isn't clickbait enough. That said, if going full-hyperbole, please consider "SLAMS" or "BLASTS" or "DESTROYS" next time.
@ 1990_ -- Sorry, I thought it was clear based on the "breach" being of the "rules." Wasn't at all thinking of what you're referring to, but breach also has the meaning of "an act of breaking, violating, or failing to fulfill a law, rule, contract, promise, or security system."
Ohh. 'Breach'... of contract. Got it. Makes sense. Wouldn't want to... hijack... the comments section... I mean, 'distract' from the story... *gulp* (Thanks for clarifying!)
Ben - 1990 is upset for "noncompliance" with N.Y Times vocabulary . I understood "breach" in the sense of "a breach of the safety rules" , and applaud the enforcement of same . Ben's wording was correct and understood .
Now that we have Israel showing how to do it , let's have a rule against mobile phone users walking into fire hydrants . The mobile phone might damage the fire hydrant .
@Alert
Israel already did that to people with pagers walking into fire hydrants.
No hydrants were harmed but over 40 people were killed and thousands were injured.
Well 1990_ here's a conspiracy for you.
JT610 was piloted by an Indonesian.
ET302 was Ethiopian.
Now 6+1+0+3+0+2=12
And this flight ET3414.
3+4+1+4= Mossad fingerprints all over it.
Mossad is really trying to keep the masquerade convincing.
What's the masquerade?
Good Idea . USA ought to have even more carefully thought-out rules for visa applications . For example , if a citizen of N.Y. wishes to have a visa for Alaska , there ought to be rules .
Alert, you may be on to something here. California operates 16 Border Protection Stations (BPS) along its land borders with Oregon, Nevada, and Arizona to inspect incoming vehicles and prevent the introduction of invasive pests. Now I hear Texas and Florida are considering operating BPS to keep out invasive pests from California.
This comment section has become the special education section of the blogosphere.
Oh Yeah !